October 28, 2008

A Better Country: Why America was Right to Confront Iraq

... As the 2008 election approaches, Americans have a civic duty to reassess the war in Iraq ...

The past six years have seen a plethora of book titles devoted to the Iraq war debate. While for the most part they painted a negative picture early on some, but not all recent titles draw the opposite conclusion. I was recently introduced to one such title, A Better Country: Why America was Right to Confront Iraq. Written by a member of The Greatest Generation and a Democrat, Arthur Borden’s book is not merely another polemic but an account as seen through the mind of a career lawyer who enlightens readers within the context of modern U.S. foreign policy in the region.

… Borden a graduate of Yale University and Columbia Law School guides readers through the historical events leading up to the 2003 invasion, focusing on the emotionally charged public debate while also navigating the politics, opposition, and responsibility of the U. S. to address the Iraqi regime. A Better Country reminds us that, stretching back to the presidency of Jimmy Carter and before, there had been a broad consensus over the touchstone issues of Iraq, the Middle East, and the unmentionable reality of oil – until political argument became degraded by charges of betrayal and wholesale deception … It sets the record straight on the threat of Saddam’s regime and on the U.S. decision to invade Iraq. It cuts through the confusions of the war debate, and it will help to overcome the deep and disabling divisions in America’s civic life.

With a razor-sharp legal mind, he presents the testimony of presidents, congressman, senators, and other foreign policy architects on both sides of the political spectrum, who for the last several decades acknowledged that a secure Persian Gulf region is crucial to American survival.
It should not surprise many that my view is in accord with that of the author in any event, a belief based on at least two premises.

1. That many on the left, including the sensitized anti-Bush and anti war horde have a fixed unaccountable interest in American failure in Iraq (and Afghanistan) and that increasingly this horde has come to include many well to do, sensible and overly righteous educated types who see failure as necessary outcome to dent American pride and honor and

2. History being a sound judge proves that the U.S. is not the power hungry bloodthirsty conqueror that takes away liberty as many extremists suggest. I do not recall an America taking away any freedom or hijack resources during WWII; they fought and won on the back of sound principles. After the conflict they worked together with and rebuilt Western Europe while enemies of America took hold of the eastern part of the continent. By the 1990’s Western Europe was modern and thriving while the Eastern states were poor and driven under. It is much the same with North and South Korea. Even in Vietnam where America lost, things are on the up because they have chosen to pursue freedom at the expense of socialist ideology.

America only profited from these nations because it established trade and democratic governance not because it stole. America’s enemies, and in particular the Islamists can argue all they like about America being evil, in Afghanistan they were given a chance to demonstrate their wares, prove to us they can govern in a civilized manner, so what did they do? Recall woman dragged before crowds and shot. Islamists having been given a chance to validate their model ways and failed dismally, hence it is time we supported America in Iraq and Afghanistan.

In terms of historical analysis as a wartime President, Bush like Truman before him, is in line for positive reconsideration.

As both the media release and Arthur Borden outlines, “As the 2008 election approaches, Americans have a civic duty to reassess the war in Iraq.”

A Better Country: Why America was Right to Confront Iraq is necessary reading for all of us seeking not just better understanding, but also a sense of finely honed discernment about how America arrived at where she is today.

8 comments:

GrEaT sAtAn'S gIrLfRiEnD said...

Essential reading indeed OtTo! Thanks for the heads up.

Your conclusion is quite correct. History will be very sweet to W.

MK said...

Thanks for letting us know Otto.

"In terms of historical analysis as a wartime President, Bush like Truman before him, is in line for positive reconsideration."

Yes, in regards to Iraq, he should be, but i don't know if the MSM of today and the people of today can see beyond the half-empty.

Bloviating Zeppelin said...

The most important point here, I believe, is that unlike a great many other countries the United States does not HOLD a nation for its own and has historically assisted in the rebuilding of affected nations. In terms of Iraq, I DEFY anyone to determine that America has done ANYTHING with the oil in Iraq, from "stealing" it to diverting it to making a profit from it.

BZ

Karen said...

I will put this book in the to-read stack. Sounds really interesting. Thanks, Otto.

WomanHonorThyself said...

Truly inspirational Otto..thanks I needed the hit!!

Straight Talk on McCain said...

When will we finally get to know the real McCain? http://straighttalkonmccain.blogspot.com/

Jennifer said...

[History being a sound judge proves that the U.S. is not the power hungry bloodthirsty conqueror that takes away liberty as many extremists suggest.]

I agree 100%. We have gotten a bad reputation but what have we truly conquered? We are unlike Hitler or Stalin. We protect our country and have lended our assistance to anyone in need and yet we are criticized time and time again. This sounds like a very interesting book but the ones that need to read it most probably never will.

Glad your back Otto, we missed you!

Tapline said...

otto, I took down the author and title, I will definately read the book. Perhaps others will read it with an open mind. If so maybe a fresh look will open people's eyes and see that the US isn't the monster portrayed by both the US media and the Democrats then echoed around the world....Excellent post as usual....stay well...